13 – PUNISHMENTS of DIYAT – KAFFÂRAT

‘Diyat’ means ‘pecuniary fine to be paid by the murderer’. ‘Ersh’, on the other hand, is a pecuniary fine levied for crimes that do not involve death. Fine to be levied for a homicide perpetrated with ‘shabah-i-’amd’, (which has been defined earlier in the text,) is a heavy diyat, i.e. (payment of) a hundred camels. Twenty-five of the camels shall have reached the age of two; twenty-five of them shall be at least three years old, twenty-five of them four years old, and the last twenty-five have to be five years old; and all of them shall be female camels. According to a few Islamic scholars, a thousand gold dinârs may be paid, instead. ‘Dinâr’ means a minted gold coin weighing a mithqâl.[1] The diyat to be paid by a person who has committed a homicide by mistake is, again, a hundred camels. Yet this time the number of each age-group of the young camels cited in the former case shall be twenty, and twenty other two-year old male camels in addition. Or, a thousand gold dinârs, or ten thousand dirhams of silver, may be paid, instead. According to the Two Imâms ‘rahmatullâhi ta’âlâ ‘alaihima’, the person who committed the crime has a choice to make between any one of these three alternatives and two hundred head of cattle or two thousand sheep or two hundred two-piece sets of clothing such as pants-and-shirt, [and trousers-and-jacket.]

Kaffârat for these two types of homicide, as well as for homicide by way of the cause of a mistake, (i.e. the aforesaid fourth type of homicide,) is to manumit a slave who is a Mu’min, (i.e. a Believer in the Islamic religion.) A person who is unable to do so will fast for two months running. Kaffârat in this respect does not contain the version of feeding poor people. (Please scan the sixth chapter of the fifth fascicle of Endless Bliss!) Diyat for a woman murdered is half that for a man murdered. Diyat for a dhimmî or a musta’min (murdered) is identical with that for a Muslim.

Diyats for crimes of depriving a person of a limb or of natural beauty are identical with the diyats for the aforesaid crimes. A complete diyat will be paid for limbs of which every individual person has a single one, such as a nose, a tongue, and a male genital organ. Other losses that require a complete diyat are sensory and motional deprivations such as mental derangement;

---------------------------------

[1]  Please see the fourth kind of ‘hadd’ in the tenth chapter for ‘mithqâl’.

-200-

psychiatric disorder; deafness; loss of sense of taste; anosmia; loss of sight; loss of speech; a paralyzed hand; and enuresis. A complete diyat will be paid for both of double limbs such as eyes; ears; eye-brows; lips; breasts of a woman; and feet, and half a diyat for one of each pair. With limbs that are in quartets, e.g. eye-lashes, a quarter diyat will be paid for each row; one-tenth of a diyat will be paid for a finger or toe; and one-twentieth of a diyat for a tooth. A complete diyat will be required for having a person’s hair or beard shaved in such a manner as it will never grow again. If the hair or the beard grows again a year later, the person who had it shaved by using force will not have to pay diyat. However, he will be punished for having committed an act that is not halâl.

Qisâs for hair and beard is inapplicable. A diyat for a woman’s tooth is half one that is for a man’s.

If a person causes a woman to abort her unborn baby by hitting her or giving her a drug, that person’s ’âqila will pay one-twentieth of a diyat. A complete diyat will have to be paid if the baby is aborted alive and dies thereafter.

If a woman has an abortion or gets her nonviable fetus aborted by using drugs or other methods without her husband’s permission, her ’âqila will pay one-twentieth of a diyat, which is worth five hundred dirhams of silver, to the woman’s husband. Nothing will be required if the husband consented to the process.

’Âqila means ‘murderer’s ‘jihâd’ companions, assistants’. The ’âqila of a murderer who does not have such assistants are his tribe, who are his assistants, or his kinsfolk. ‘Fellow villagers’ or ‘fellow citizens’ is meant by ‘his tribe’. The diyat incumbent upon the murderer will be charged in certain shares to these assistants of his, and it will be exacted within three years. The amount to be exacted from one person in three years cannot be more than four dirhams (of silver). Women or children or insane people will not be included in the ’âqila. A disbeliever and a Muslim will not be ’âqila for each other.

If a Muslim murderer does not have ’âqila or inheritors, his diyat will be paid by the Beyt-ul-mâl, i.e. by the government. If there is not a Beyt-ul-mâl, either, he himself will pay it within three years. If a dhimmî does not have ’âqila, he himself will pay the ’âqila in three years. A Muslim who kills another Muslim in the Dâr-ul-harb will pay the diyat incumbent on him in three years. It is out of the question there to be ’âqila in the Dâr-ul-harb. Non-Arabians called ’ajams cannot have ’âqila.

-201-

It is stated as follows in the fatwâ of Abu-s-su’ûd Efendi ‘rahmatullâhi ta’âlâ ‘alaih’, [no. 706,] which exists in the Lala Ismâ’îl section of the Library of Suleymâniyye, (in Istanbul:) “If a dead person is found hanging in a house or shop, its diyat will be paid by the landlord, according to Imâm A’zam Abû Hanîfa ‘rahmatullâhi ta’âlâ ’alaih’, and by the tenant, according to Imâm Abû Yûsuf ‘rahmatullâhi ta’âlâ ’alaih’. The fatwâ is in agreement with Abû Yûsuf’s ijtihâd.”

A look from a scholar is a treasure hardly attainable;
Sohbat in his presence is a library inexhaustible.